Western Digital Corporation
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
SCHEDULE TO
(RULE 14d-100)
TENDER OFFER STATEMENT UNDER SECTION 14(d)(1) OR 13(e)(1) OF THE
SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
Komag, Incorporated
(Name of Subject Company)
Western Digital Corporation
State M Corporation
(Name of Person(s) Filing Statement (Offerors))
Common Stock, $.01 par value per share
(Title of Class of Securities)
500453204
(CUSIP Number of Class of Securities)
Raymond
M. Bukaty
Senior Vice President, Administration, General Counsel and Secretary
Western Digital Corporation
20511 Lake Forest Drive
Lake Forest, California 92630
(949) 672-7000
(Name, Address and Telephone Number of Person
Authorized to Receive Notices and Communications on Behalf of Filing Persons)
Copy to:
Jay Herron, Esq.
Steve L. Camahort, Esq.
OMelveny & Myers LLP
610 Newport Center Drive
17th Floor
Newport Beach, CA 92660
(949) 760-9600
Calculation of Filing Fee
|
|
|
|
Transaction Valuation:*
|
|
Amount of Filing Fee:* |
|
*Not Applicable
|
|
*Not Applicable |
|
o Check box if any part of the fee is offset as provided by Rule 0-11 (a) (2) and
identity the filing with which the offsetting fee was previously paid. Identify the previous
filing by registration statement number, or the Form or Schedule and the date of its filing.
x Check box if the filing relates solely to preliminary communications made before the
commencement of a tender offer.
Check the appropriate boxes below to designate any transactions to which the statement relates:
x third-party offer subject to Rule 14d-1
o issuer tender offer subject to Rule 13e-4
o going-private transactions subject to Rule 13e-3
o amendment to Schedule 13D under Rule 13d-2
Jun. 28. 2007 / 5:00PM, WDC Western Digital to Acquire Komag
CORPORATE PARTICIPANTS
Bob Blair
Western Digital Corp. VP, IR
John Coyne
Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Tim Leyden
Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
Tim Harris
Komag CEO
CONFERENCE CALL PARTICIPANTS
Rich Kugele
Needham & Company Analyst
Paul Mansky
Citigroup Analyst
Kevin Hunt
Thomas Weisel Analyst
Mark Moskowitz
JPMorgan Analyst
Min Park
Goldman Sachs Analyst
Dan Renouard
Robert Baird Analyst
Mark Miller
Brean Murray Analyst
Christian Schwab
Craig-Hallum Analyst
Sherri Scribner
Deutsche Bank Analyst
Keith Bachman
Bank of Montreal Analyst
Harry Blount
Lehman Brothers Analyst
Bill Hand
Bear Stearns Analyst
Matt Kather
WR Hambrecht Analyst
Shaw Wu
American Technology Research Analyst
PRESENTATION
Operator
1
Welcome to the Western Digital and Komag conference call.
Presently, all participants are in a listen-only mode. Later, we will conduct a question and answer session.
At this time, if you would like to ask a question, you may press star-1 on your touchtone phone. As a
reminder, this call is being recorded.
Now I would like to turn the conference call over to Mr. Bob Blair. You may begin.
Bob Blair - Western Digital Corp. VP, IR
Thank you
and welcome to the Western Digital and Komag conference call. As we
begin, I want to remind
you that we will be making forward-looking statements in our comments and in response to your
questions concerning the anticipating closing date of the transaction with Komag announced today
and WDs expectations regarding funding of the transaction, WDs business and market expansion
strategies, including WDs strategy to be one of the hard drive
industrys leaders, WDs beliefs
regarding the strategic benefits of sourcing media internally, WDs media supply strategy after
completion of the transaction announced today, and WDs expectations regarding the financial impact
to the company of the transaction announced today, including the financial impact on WDs gross
margin, depreciation, and amortization expense, operating expenses and other key financial
metrics.
These forward-looking statements are based on the current expectations of WDs and Komags
management and are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ
materially, including those listed in WDs and Komags filings with the SEC including our Form
10-Qs filed with the SEC for the quarter ended March 31, 2007
and April 1, 2007, respectively, as
well as the additional risk factors reported in the press release we will file with the SEC today.
We undertake no obligation to update our forward-looking statements to reflect new information or
events and you should not assume later in the quarter that the comments we make today are still
valid. I would now like to turn the call over to John Coyne, President and Chief Executive Officer
of Western Digital. John?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Thanks, Bob. Good afternoon, everyone. Thank you for joining us on this call to announce our
agreement to acquire Komag. With me today are Steve Milligan, Chief Financial Officer of WD; Tim
Leyden, Western Digitals Executive Vice President of Finance; and Tim Harris, CEO of Komag.
Let me begin with a brief overview of the transaction announced today, which has been unanimously
recommended by both companies board of directors. WD has made a $984 million cash offer to acquire
Komag at $32.25 per Komag share. We expect to fund the acquisition through a combination of
company cash and a term loan. This will be structured as a tender offer and back-end cash merger
with the transaction expected to close in calendar Q3 2007, subject to customary regulatory
approvals and other closing conditions.
I would now like to share some of our thinking and intent in taking this important strategic
step. Afterwards, Tim Leyden will address some of the advantages that we expect to achieve in the
WD business model from this combination, and Tim Harris will speak about the rationale for Komag in
taking this step. We will then take your questions.
I think its important to note that for competitive reasons, we will not provide as much
quantitative information today as you might prefer, but that we expect to be in a position to
provide more information when the transaction closes. I would also like to mention that the focus
of todays call and the Q&A will be solely on the transaction announced today. Given the timing of
todays announcement at the end of the June quarter, neither WD nor Komag will be addressing
industry conditions nor WDs outlook for the current quarter on this call. However, I would call to
your attention to Komags separate press release today about their revised outlook for the June
quarter.
This acquisition of Komag by WD is strategic. It positions WD as a leading vertically integrated
hard drive supplier for years to come. Having our own internal media supply will enable us to
compete more efficiently. We will be better positioned to invest in innovation and develop new
technologies, enhancing our ability to compete at the cutting edge of this business. On an
2
industry note, todays announcement is a continuation of a trend weve seen playing out in
the last several years of asset rationalization, a good thing for this industry and our customers.
We have seen the consolidation of HDD suppliers and a thinning of the merchant supply base for
critical technology components such as heads and media. Having control of the key technologies has
become even more important in this context.
As Western Digital has grown profitably to become the worlds second largest HDD supplier, the
advantages of controlling our own destiny over the development and supply of these components and
being able to capture the synergies between them at the system level has become increasingly
evident. It is important to consider that Western Digital has a strong track record of integrating
acquired operations quickly and efficiently. Beginning in 2003, we recognized and achieved the
advantages of greater vertical integration when we acquired and integrated the assets of Read-Rite.
This assured us of long-term access to head technology and the opportunity for improvement in
operational flexibility in an industry where short cycle times and high quality are increasingly
important.
Additionally, we successfully integrated the desktop hard drive manufacturing operations of Fujitsu
in Thailand in 2001. Over the last seven years, we have built a successful business model and track
record based on the attributes of quality, reliability, high asset efficiency, crisp executions,
and a competitive cost structure. Managing high volume manufacturing operations efficiently is what
we do for a living at Western Digital, and we do it with great passion and focus.
While there are significant differences between the acquisitions of Read-Rite and Komag, we see the
opportunity to further enhance our cost leadership model and to achieve many of the same long-term
strategic benefits in acquiring Komag. In contrast to Read-Rite at the time of its acquisition by
WD in 2003, Komag is a highly efficient, highly utilized operation with good technology that is
executing well for its customers. I would also note that Komag is an industry leader in shipment of
perpendicular magnetic recording media. The physical proximity, cultural similarities, and
integration of the two companies R&D organizations in Northern California and our manufacturing
operations in Malaysia and Thailand are expected to advance our ongoing mission to tighten our
supply chain and achieve low-cost, high-velocity leadership in the industry.
Another factor in our decision was one of scale. WD is now the worlds second largest supplier of
hard drives, and this acquisition puts the company in a position to be in greater control of its
own destiny in the dynamic storage marketplace, further differentiating us from many other players
in the industry.
Now let me
address our media supply strategy post-Komag acquisition. While we plan to provide the
majority of our media needs internally, we will continue to source significant volumes from the
merchant market. We greatly value our supplier relationships and we look forward to continued
mutually beneficial business in the future. This hybrid media supply strategy will enable WD to
benchmark its own technology against the best available merchant media, hedge our execution risk,
and share our total development costs. This approach has worked extremely well with heads and we
believe it is equally applicable for media.
We do not underestimate the challenge we face. But figuring out how to make assets and operations
work more efficiently is a key part of the Western Digital DNA, and we look forward to doing
exactly that with Tim Harris and the rest of the Komag team and we welcome them to Western Digital.
I would now ask Tim Leyden to address the financial impact of the acquisition. Tim?
Tim Leyden - Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
Thanks, John. I would now like to describe the terms of the Komag acquisition and then share with
you some of the financial parameters of the transaction and its potential impact on our long-term
business model. We currently estimate that the total cost of the acquisition would be approximately
$1 billion, consisting of cash paid for Komags outstanding stock, employee stock equivalents, and
other costs of the acquisition.
3
From an accounting point of view, the acquisition will result in fair value adjustments to
Komags carrying costs of assets and liabilities, including recognition of intangible assets such
as purchase technology. This will result in incremental depreciation and amortization expense for
the next several years. The amount of this incremental non-cash expense will be based on valuation
work that will be performed in conjunction with the acquisition. In addition, we expect there will
be a one-time charge for in-process research and development in the quarter in which the
acquisition closes. As indicated in our press release, this transaction would be funded through a
combination of cash and debt. To that end, we have secured a term loan of up to $1.25 billion.
Now let me take you through the expected impact of the acquisition on the next several quarters.
For the March quarter, WD accounted for approximately 35% of Komags revenue. Komags other major
customers are Seagate and Hitachi. Post-closing, we are prepared to provide all customers with the
committed volumes outlined in their existing volume purchase arrangement. However, customers will
determine their media and substrate requirement.
Therefore, there could be a significant reduction in volume from those customers that will not be
immediately replaced by our own internal requirements. Accordingly, we believe it is prudent to
model a short-term negative impact to our gross margin related to unabsorbed fixed costs. This
short-term impact could last for approximately three quarters
post-closing. This impact could be $25
to $30 million per quarter. Additionally, we expect some exceptional transition-related costs
totaling approximately $20 to $30 million. The amortization of intangibles resulting from fair value
adjustments for the media assets will be approximately $20 to $30 million per quarter. We expect to
be able to provide more specifics on this subject after we close the transaction.
From an operating expense standpoint, our spending is expected to increase by about $20 million per
quarter, most of which will be for ongoing media-related research and development. Also our fourth
quarter will include a one-time charge for in process research and development.
Turning to
our business model, John has outlined several of the operational benefits of the
acquisition. As indicated, we now expect to produce a significant amount of our media volumes
internally. We will continue to procure meaningful volumes from the
merchant market. We believe
that on a long-term basis, our costs will decrease, resulting in a potential increase to our gross
margin of approximately 250 basis points. Our net margins will potentially improve by up to 100
basis points once the full benefits of the acquisition have been realized. From a balance sheet
perspective, we expect that a more vertically integrated enterprise will require increased
inventory levels that might fluctuate based on the market condition for precious metals.
Consequently, we expect our inventory terms to reduce. Historically our inventory terms have ranged
from 18 to 20.
Lastly, capital expenditures when viewed as an average over several years will increase by
approximately $80 million annually to sustain current capacity. Excluding the impact from
amortization of acquisition-related intangibles, we expect the acquisition to be accretive to
earnings by the first quarter of fiscal 2009. Now Ill turn the call over to Tim Harris.
Tim Harris - Komag CEO
Thank you, Tim. This is an exciting time for Komag and all of its constituents. Given the ongoing
rationalization of assets throughout our global industry, the acquisition of Komag by WD is the
natural next step in the close customer-supplier relationship between the two companies. This is a
good transaction for WD, for Komag, and for the entire HDD industry. The transaction we announced
today will provide our shareholders with an attractive price as well as value certainty in this
dynamic industry.
WD is
already a closely embedded customer in Komags processes and is therefore
uniquely positioned to benefit from Komags media capabilities. As John has indicated, the two
companies have a great deal in common culturally and in their focus on operational excellence. On
behalf of the Komag team, we look forward to being part of the WD organization and delivering our
leading technology, know-how, and execution capabilities to the continued success of WD. John?
4
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Thank you, Tim. Operator, we will now open the call to questions.
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, we will now begin the question and answer
session portion of todays call. If you have a question, please press star-1 on your touchtone phone. If you would
like to withdraw your question, please press star-2. One moment please for the first question. Our first question comes
from Rich Kugele, and please state your company
name.
Rich Kugele - Needham & Company Analyst
Needham & Company. Thank you. Just a few questions for this first round here. Can you give us a
sense, Tim, on what you think the reasonable debt-cash percentage mix might be just so we can begin
to triangulate the costs?
Tim Leyden - Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
Debt cash,
we really havent finalized what our eventual capital structure will be, but we are
evaluating that. In the short-term obviously were going to have
the draw down on the $1.25 billion
loan.
Rich Kugele - Needham & Company Analyst
Okay, so youll pull that down anyway?
Tim Leyden - Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
Yes.
Rich Kugele - Needham & Company Analyst
And then
you talked how you will, within the context of the long-term
contracts, offer to Komags
customers continued supply. Is there any provision, though, in those contracts under change of
control where you can get out of them if you want to?
Tim
Leyden - Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
There are provisions in change of control that leave the decision up to the customer.
Rich Kugele - Needham & Company Analyst
Okay. And
is that the same case for the substrate side? I know that Komag as being the largest
producer of substrates produced greater than its own requirements, which means it would be greater
than your own requirements. Do you have a point of view on that side of the business?
5
Tim
Leyden - Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
Similar
provisions in the volume purchase agreements. And yes, the Komag substrate facility and
operation is a class act in the industry and we would certainly be
happy to continue to supply substrates to
customers, outside our own needs.
Rich Kugele - Needham & Company Analyst
Okay. And then just lastly, this is for Tim Harris. Although many of your customers were qualified
on all three of your lines, sometimes they did have preferences. Do you anticipate taking down any
of the lines that WD has historically not been interested in ahead of the transaction? Or will you
make any restructuring actions ahead of the actual merger?
Tim Harris - Komag CEO
You know, we havent got that deep into it. I guess I believe that all of our technologies will work
efficiently for PMR and well just take it from there.
Rich Kugele - Needham & Company Analyst
Okay, and congratulations. Good idea.
Tim Harris - Komag CEO
Thank you.
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Thanks Rich.
Operator
Our next question comes from Paul Mansky. Please announce your company name.
Paul Mansky - Citigroup Analyst
Yes, its Citigroup. Kind of following up on the volume purchase agreement question. Relative to
that $25 to $30 million per quarter gross margin hit over the
next three quarters, what are your
underlying assumptions as it relates to the keep rate on the VPAs?
Tim Leyden - Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
What we have modeled is zero.
Paul Mansky - Citigroup Analyst
Okay. Okay. So thats that would be a worst case scenario. Okay. As we look out over the next
year to two years, your largest competitor likes to keep it in the
10% to 15% outsource mix on the media
side. When you talk about when you look at your ideal mix, would that closely mirror that
number?
6
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Well, Paul, our approach has been different. When we did the head acquisition, we indicated a
substantial minority of our demand being outside, and weve run
in the 70% to 80% internal head
model. And we saw a similar model working in media.
Paul Mansky - Citigroup Analyst
Great.
Thank you very much, and congratulations again.
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Thank you.
Operator
Our next question comes from Kevin Hunt. Please state your company name.
Kevin Hunt - Thomas Weisel Analyst
Thomas
Weisel. Couple of follow-up questions. In terms of those, the volume purchases, how long are
those, again?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
They are of different lengths, but the majority through the end of 2008.
Kevin Hunt - Thomas Weisel Analyst
Okay. And
so youre just so I understand this properly, so either the customers with those
agreements have the option of sustaining them for the whole time or ending them early. But you said
youre modeling the worst case of ending them early and thus having excess capacity when youre
giving those gross margin number hits?
John
Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
With the
reference to the impact that could be $25 to $30 million thats correct, yes.
Kevin Hunt - Thomas Weisel Analyst
Okay. Now what in terms of whats, I guess your anticipation of how fast you could bring up
lets say people did we dont need those agreements, that would obviously give you excess
capacity, how fast could you fill that from your own demand or are there other hurdles you have to
get over that would not allow you to fill that immediately?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
In
Tims remarks, he indicated three quarters where we could be affected, and so that gives you an
idea of the transition relative to our ability to bring up lines to the WD recipe as well as
influenced by our existing obligations to our merchant suppliers.
7
Kevin Hunt - Thomas Weisel Analyst
Okay. So
that three quarters is assuming you guys went off of went to another supplier to get
three quarters probably to ramp-up? Is that the fair way to think about it?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Yes.
Kevin Hunt - Thomas Weisel Analyst
Okay. Another I guess a question more for Komag, guys. Can you give any color of why youre
down 30% sequentially? That seems like a fairly material issue happening at the Company that
requires an explanation on this call, I would think.
Tim Harris - Komag CEO
Weve
updated our Q2 outlook. Well not have any other comments at this time, and we will discuss
those Q2 results thoroughly in our normal earnings release.
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
And I
think relative to this call, this has no bearing on the outlook for a
WD Komag combined WD
media facility.
Kevin Hunt - Thomas Weisel Analyst
Okay. So youre I guess comfortable that theres not some technology problem or some issue going on
here?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Absolutely.
Kevin Hunt - Thomas Weisel Analyst
Okay. Oh
and one other question whats happening within the Komag converts? Are they getting
retired as part of this? Or what goes on there?
John
Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Our
intention is to retire the Komag convert after the transaction.
Kevin Hunt - Thomas Weisel Analyst
Okay. Thank you.
8
Operator
Our next question comes from Mark Moskowitz. Sir, please state your company name.
Mark Moskowitz - JPMorgan Analyst
Yes, good afternoon, JPMorgan. My first question, I guess, gets back to Kevins question as far as
the Komag quarter in terms of down 30% sequentially. If we?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Mark, I dont think we want to go there on this call. This call is about the combination and the
future.
Mark Moskowitz - JPMorgan Analyst
Let me tackle it a different way in a more succinct fashion. I guess if we think about the future
prospects of standalone Komag if this type of profile was to
continue, and we think about how you
acquired Read-Rite back in 2003 after that Company fell down on both
knees Im just trying to get
a sense, was there another bidder out there, another suiter out there for Komag in terms of why
youre buying them now versus later?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
I think the issue of the combination is the strategic value to Western Digital of having control
both of the technology and the supply line to service our needs for profitable growth into the
future and to fuel our ability to accelerate technology in terms of the synergies between our heads
and media. That relates to factors such as the transition to PMR,
Komags progress, glass PMR, and
similar factors.
Mark Moskowitz - JPMorgan Analyst
And then as far as the overall industry, I know you dont want to talk about the broader industry
conditions, but should we think about how should we think about oversupply right now? Is the
industry in oversupply?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
I think as
we indicated in March in the March call, media supply was well balanced, maybe slightly
long.
Mark Moskowitz - JPMorgan Analyst
And then,
John, as far as your relationships with the VPA folks in terms of the
Seagates of the world with the change of
control, do they get their money back if they dont want to keep using Komag? How does that work?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
They get the residual money back.
9
Mark Moskowitz - JPMorgan Analyst
And can you tell us how much that is?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
No.
Mark Moskowitz - JPMorgan Analyst
Okay. And then?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
We have factored it into our overall numbers.
Mark Moskowitz - JPMorgan Analyst
Okay. And then a question for Tim Leyden as far as the OPEX guidance. I think you suggested we
should model about $20 million incremental OPEX per quarter, is that correct?
Tim Leyden - Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
Yes, in the immediate future.
Mark Moskowitz - JPMorgan Analyst
And then
just lastly, how should we think about depreciation as far as from Komag, just given that
there seem to be some sort of bewilderment in the past in terms of how their CAPEX had a pretty big
uptake, but there wasnt a commensurate money or uptake in terms of the appreciation, in terms of
some sort of delayed effect. Does that mean youre going to have higher depreciation going forward
than we would expect?
Tim Leyden - Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
Were
not were not anticipating that. We have modeled in a
number of $25 to $30 million and
thats where we anticipate that its going to be on a run rate basis.
Mark Moskowitz - JPMorgan Analyst
Okay. Thank you.
Operator
Our next question comes from Min Park, please state your company name.
10
Min Park - Goldman Sachs Analyst
Goldman Sachs. Just a couple brief questions. Can you just tell us if there was any other
competitors bidding for the Komag assets or if this was just purely a negotiated deal?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Well, I can tell you that we negotiated this deal with Komag. And were announcing that deal today.
Min Park - Goldman Sachs Analyst
You cant tell us if theres other competitors bidding for the assets?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
I cant tell you.
Min Park - Goldman Sachs Analyst
Okay. And
second, if customers do have control in the supplier agreements, shouldnt WD be able to
actually internally source Komag platters very quickly should Seagate
and Hitachi decide to end their relationship?
Why should we expect a three quarter lag before theyre actually
able to ramp up Komag?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Yes, we
have Komag qualified on all of our platforms, and the issue is the rate at which at this
point what were advising you is that should the existing customers pull all of their business, it
would take sometime to bring up all of those lines to the WD recipe. We also have existing
obligations with our external merchant market partners that we will
honor, and so there is a
transition period before we reach the full utilization model that we anticipate as the long-term
benefit of this acquisition.
Min Park - Goldman Sachs Analyst
Okay. Thank you.
Operator
Our next question comes from Dan Renouard. Please state your company name.
Dan Renouard - Robert Baird Analyst
Hi, its Robert Baird. I have a couple of questions. First is, can you talk about the timeline to
the deal? How long were you guys in discussions? And then also to the extent that you can give us
any sense for timing of the close? I mean if youre expecting a
fairly quick close is there any reason why it would
be an extended close, i.e. late in Q3, early in Q3? Thanks.
11
Tim
Leyden- Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
The transaction is structured as a tender offer,
which we expect to launch shortly with the closing
during calendar Q3 2007, and obviously were subject to the various customary closing conditions
including regulatory approval. That gives you an idea of the timing.
Dan Renouard - Robert Baird Analyst
Can you talk about the timeline to actually negotiating this transaction?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
No, I dont think thats relevant.
Dan Renouard - Robert Baird Analyst
Is there any sort of a collar or a breakup fee?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Yes, there is a breakup fee and the tender documentation will show that.
Dan Renouard - Robert Baird Analyst
Thats being filed tonight?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Tomorrow.
Dan Renouard - Robert Baird Analyst
Tomorrow. And then last question is can you give us any sort of a sense and maybe this is in your
itll be in your filing, but what kind of terms on the loan did you get?
John
Coyne- Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Obviously
it depends on the rating we achieve, but we anticipate a favorable rating. We have taken
a conservative view when we modeled the market rate.
Dan Renouard - Robert Baird Analyst
Okay. And that will we wont know that tomorrow though well know that in the coming weeks?
12
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Yes.
Dan Renouard - Robert Baird Analyst
Thank you.
Operator
Our next question comes from Mark Miller. Please state your company name.
Mark Miller - Brean Murray Analyst
Mark Miller from Brean Murray. You probably addressed this, but Im just wondering if you can give
us a little more color into your thought process. Weve been listening to or asking questions about
the possibility of Western Digital vertically integrating the media for sometime. We were always
told that you thought that that was not necessary. Im just
wondering do you feel the industrys
becoming far more competitive or technologically challenged? What
really changed this, say, over the
last year?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Well, I think, Mark, what weve
consistently indicated is that at those times, while we were not in
a position to make this move, that we never say never and we continually evaluate the environment.
As we look today at the overall consolidations that have been
happening in the industry, at the
current shape of the industry, the elements of ability to enhance and accelerate our technology and
have our hands on that set of wheels, as well as the ability to secure and control continuity of
supply, those two elements combined were the primary drivers here. And of
course, it helps that over time it will benefit our cost structure.
Mark Miller - Brean Murray Analyst
Do you feel this will result in any other strategic moves? This certainly leaves Samsung out in the
cold as not being vertically integrated and they have ambitions. Im just curious about any
longer term strategic moves you could see in the industry because of it.
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Well, Id prefer not to speculate on that. But certainly were very positive on the impact on
Western Digitals competitive position.
Mark Miller - Brean Murray Analyst
And
finally, I know the fabs are pretty well filled up, but is it possible you could use some of the
Malaysian fab space, say, as an alternative site for head production?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Well, the facilities as you know are quite well filled up. However, there is some available land
for expansion that could potentially host any one of our operations going into the future. Were
very pleased with the synergies of this acquisition relative to supply
13
chain integration are very good. Our footprint for manufacturing with the media heads and
drives in Malaysia and Thailand connected by road transport is very tight, probably the best
logistics footprint in the industry.
Mark Miller - Brean Murray Analyst
And
finally, what about the glass substrates in terms of youre certainly the leader in aluminum.
But is there any strategy to get more vertically integrated through
glass or its just a question but thats a big thing for the future.
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
I think,
as you know, Komag had been
working hard on glass media, and that will continue. As to the
glass substrate we have some very expert suppliers whose business
forte that is, and they have
been very supportive of the effort so far.
Mark Miller - Brean Murray Analyst
Thank you.
Congratulations again.
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Thank you.
Operator
Our next question comes from Christian Schwab. Please state your company name.
Christian Schwab - Craig-Hallum Analyst
Craig-Hallum Capital Group, congratulations. Could you remind us what your, roughly what your
average platter count is per drive today?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Its about 1.7.
Christian Schwab - Craig-Hallum Analyst
Great. And then do you think by acquiring Komag that this could help accelerate your opportunity to
introduce enterprise drives faster?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Not specifically. But it certainly facilitates over time our ability to improve our time to market
due to the integration of the head and media engineering efforts.
14
Christian Schwab - Craig-Hallum Analyst
Great. No further questions. Thanks.
Operator
Our next question comes from Sherri Scribner. Please state your company name.
Sherri Scribner - Deutsche Bank Analyst
Hi, thank you, its Deutsche Bank. Can you
just quickly comment on the share count assumptions that
youre using for the deal, and does that include the convertible debt?
John
Coyne- Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Yes,
were using 30.5 million as the share count.
Sherri Scribner - Deutsche Bank Analyst
Okay.
John
Coyne- Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
That does include the convertible debt.
Sherri Scribner - Deutsche Bank Analyst
Okay. Great. And then in terms of Komags
ramp of glass media, have you qualified Komags glass
media at this point? And how important was Komags ramp of perpendicular media, their sort of time
line and just what you saw in terms of their products pipeline that made you interested in buying
them?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
I think
the fundamental one of the fundamental drivers here is the fact that Komag has led the
industry in perpendicular and their achievements both on aluminum and glass relative to that
technology.
Sherri Scribner - Deutsche Bank Analyst
And have you qualified their glass media yet?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
We dont talk about which media we have qualified. We dont generally talk about specific
qualification of supplier components.
15
Sherri Scribner - Deutsche Bank Analyst
Okay. And then in terms of the purchase price, I think, Tim, a couple of weeks ago we talked to you
and you talked that the asset value for the company was about $1 billion or more. It seems like
Western Digital is getting you at a relatively reasonable price considering what you said the asset
value is. Can you comment a little bit about sort of the deal price and why it maybe isnt a little
bit higher?
Tim
Harris- Komag CEO
Yes we believe that this is that we are delivering value certainty to our shareholders and at the
same time securing a good long-term future for our employees as were part of this combined entity.
And I think its also a good price and a good deal for WD.
Sherri Scribner - Deutsche Bank Analyst
Okay. Great. Thank you.
Operator
Our next question comes from Keith Bachman. Please state your company name.
Keith Bachman - Bank of Montreal Analyst
Hi, Bank of Montreal. Can you remind us of what percent WD sources its media from Komag?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
I dont think we have released that information publicly.
Keith Bachman - Bank of Montreal Analyst
Can you
release it now? Its relevant to the transaction.
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
I can you can probably work it out. I gave you the disks per drive and you know that we were 35%
of Komags business last quarter.
Keith Bachman - Bank of Montreal Analyst
Okay. Let me try another one then. If you
could you give us any characterization on where youre
not sourcing from Komag? I assume its on the notebook side, but anything on the enterprise side,
as well, or the enterprise drives, rather?
16
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Well, we have not announced any
enterprise class products. We do serve the enterprise market with
our RAID addition 3.5 aluminum-based large capacity drive families. But if you are referring to
enterprise as SCSI fiber channel, we have no announced product in that area.
Keith Bachman - Bank of Montreal Analyst
No, I was
referring to drives. The drives
you identified are you using the Komag media for that?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Oh, okay. We use Komag media in the full range of our 3.5 aluminum-based drives.
Keith Bachman - Bank of Montreal Analyst
Okay. Thank you.
Operator
Our next question comes from Harry Blount. Please state your company name.
Harry Blount - Lehman Brothers Analyst
Lehman Brothers. Couple questions. First of all,
on the Komag side of the equation, is it fair to
assume that the R&D effort at Komag is relatively split proportionately to the vendor revenue that
you supplied?
Tim
Harris- Komag CEO
Yes, although perhaps not linear. But it varies, of course, quarter to quarter depending on who is
qualifying new products and how quickly they are ramping. Thats a reasonably good assumption.
Harry Blount - Lehman Brothers Analyst
Secondly, a lot of the equipment?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Let me just interject there. You should not assume from that that we will apportion the R&D
resources the same way. We see this as an opportunity to accelerate WDs technology by applying
those resources in a focused way.
Harry Blount - Lehman Brothers Analyst
Correct. Thats exactly where I was going with the question. Youll have to be supportive of less
programs going forward.
17
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Which should allow acceleration.
Harry Blount - Lehman Brothers Analyst
Secondly, a lot of the equipment in Malaysia if memory serves is fully depreciated at this point.
And as you repurpose some of those production lines, which if memory serves are from multiple
vendors it feels like there will be some fair amount of incremental CAPEX associated, which may
also boost depreciation. Has that been fully factored into the returns?
John
Coyne- Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Yes. As you know, Komag has been a significant amount of CAPEX over the last two years building out
their increased capacity. We have no current plans to increase that capacity level other than
through improved utilization, and the current equipment lines, as you know, are at bearing ages,
and we have made assumptions relative to appropriate replacements and sustaining capital to achieve
full utilization at the current capacity.
Harry Blount - Lehman Brothers Analyst
Okay, just
want to make sure. But in terms of the accounting for the transaction, doesnt the asset
then have to be written up using this accounting treatment?
John
Coyne- Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
And we mentioned that in our
opening remarks where we have assumed some amortization as a result of
the revaluation of those assets.
Harry Blount - Lehman Brothers Analyst
Okay. Lastly, if we just do the straight
math on the net margin accretion that you guys are looking
for of about 100 bips on your $5 to $6 billion type revenue number, that would suggest a payback
around the two-year time frame once you do hit that break-even point. Am I looking at this right
that the payback will probably be in the 2.5 to 3-year range overall?
John
Coyne- Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Yes, we have an awful lot of modeling to
do yet and we have a lot of discovery to do, and we dont
know what the revaluation is going to be. But I think youre pretty much in the ballpark.
Harry Blount - Lehman Brothers Analyst
Im sorry, I did have one more, actually. Any tax consequences? Komag had some fairly meaningful
tax holidays in Malaysia. Is there any change of control provisions that may put those at risk?
18
John
Coyne- Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
We believe not. We believe we can capitalize
on the favorable situation that they had.
And as you
know, as Western Digital, we have been in Malaysia since 1973 and have very good relationships with
the Malaysian government and promotion agencies, as do Komag. And we believe this combination will
be viewed very positively there as securing the long-term future of both endeavors.
Harry Blount - Lehman Brothers Analyst
Great. Thank you very much.
Operator
Our next question comes from Andy Neff. Please state your company name.
Bill Hand - Bear Stearns Analyst
Yes, its Bill Hand for Andy from Bear Stearns.
Just getting back to the question on the valuation.
Any thoughts on the basis for the billion dollar valuation? Any relevant metrics you looked at to
get to that number?
John
Coyne- Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Weve
actually been working, as you know, with Goldman Sachs, our investment
banker, and they have
provided the fairness opinion and it does provide a very nice return on capital.
Bill Hand - Bear Stearns Analyst
Okay. Just
to clarify, you said the $25 to $30 million gross margin that you expected over the next
three quarters, that was if both Hitachi and Seagate pulled all their volumes?
John
Coyne- Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Yes. As
you know, this business is pretty sensitive to utilization rates.
Bill Hand - Bear Stearns Analyst
Sure.
John
Coyne- Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
So consequently, thats the reason
we have modeled that in the next three quarters, and it does
assume that we have zero volumes from the two other customers, significant customers.
Tim
Leyden- Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
So just in relation to that, I think I
indicated in an earlier response that VPAs had up to the end
of 2008. There are actually different termination dates on the VPAs, and they could be shorter than
that. There are some termination rights within the VPAs that
19
could make them shorter than that. But our guidance is two to three months or two to three
quarters, sorry, to get to full utilization or in the ballpark.
Bill Hand - Bear Stearns Analyst
Okay. And lastly, so you said the transaction would be accretive in 4Q 09, but youre not prepared
yet to provide a time frame as to when you might achieve those gross margin and net margin
improvements that you referenced?
John
Coyne- Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Were
not yet as we said, were early in the stages of
evaluating that, and obviously there are a
number of things that we just dont have answers on yet.
Bill Hand - Bear Stearns Analyst
Okay. Thank you.
Operator
Our next question comes from Matt Kather. Please state your company name.
Matt Kather - WR Hambrecht Analyst
Hi, WR Hambrecht. Just a follow-up question
on the operating costs for the Western Digital combined
model going forward. You mentioned $20 to $30 million per quarter and then you also said that of the
$20 million per quarter intangibles cost. Are there two separate things you wanted us to that you
were trying to explain or did you just mean a total of $20 to $30 million per quarter?
Tim Leyden - Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
I said the operating expenses were going to increase by approximately $20 million per quarter.
Matt Kather - WR Hambrecht Analyst
So that includes the amortization of intangibles?
Tim Leyden - Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
Thats a separate and additional item.
Matt Kather - WR Hambrecht Analyst
Okay. So the amortization of the intangibles
would be a separate additional $20 to $30 million a
quarter?
20
Tim Leyden - Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
Yes.
Matt Kather - WR Hambrecht Analyst
Okay. On
the CAPEX, you said additional $80 million a year on a longer
term ongoing model. Does that
factor in eventual expansion? Or is that just factoring in keeping the existing capacity that
youre buying from Komag today?
Tim Leyden - Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
Its the sustaining level for the capital at the current capacity levels. But obviously we believe
that theres some opportunity for increase through improved utilization.
Matt Kather - WR Hambrecht Analyst
So thats a maintenance number to sustain?
Tim Leyden - Western Digital Corp. EVP-Fin.
A sustaining number.
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Maintenance and technology. Obviously you need to refresh equipment in order to keep pace with the
rate of technology required for aerial density.
Matt Kather - WR Hambrecht Analyst
Last question is for Tim Harris on the Komag side. For your shareholders, this is not going to
require a vote, is that correct?
Tim Harris - Komag CEO
Thats correct.
Matt Kather - WR Hambrecht Analyst
And again, its been asked a couple of different ways, but from a Komag shareholder perspective,
maybe could you say again why you think that this is the best value for the company? Clearly some
near term challenges, but I think a lot of shareholders would view this if they had the opportunity
to vote as not a high enough price for them. So what would you say to those shareholders?
21
Tim Harris - Komag CEO
Well, weve worked well with WD for a long time in a customer-supplier relationship. As you know WD
is our largest media customer. And I guess we think that this transaction is the natural next step.
We do believe that its important that were capturing the value with an absolute degree of
certainty for our shareholders, and thats really how we look at it.
Matt Kather - WR Hambrecht Analyst
Thank you.
Operator
Our next question comes from Shaw Wu. Please state your company name.
Shaw Wu - American Technology Research Analyst
Yes, American Technology Research. Just two
questions. First, I know, Tim, you talked about
what percentage of your shipments and production those are two
separate questions, I guess is
PMR? And then the second the second question is comments that over the longer term you could
source 70% plus of your media needs internally. Does that also apply for glass, as well, glass
media? Thanks.
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Let me answer that. This is John. WD does not and will not break out our PMR, LMR, aluminum glass
ratios. However, we do intend to utilize the Komag operations to address all of our product lines
over time, given within the model of a majority internal production
20% to 30% external sourcing.
But we will participate in every kind of media.
Shaw Wu - American Technology Research Analyst
Okay. Thanks.
Operator
Once
again, to ask your question, please press star-1 on your touchtone
phone. Our next question comes from Kevin Hunt. Please state your company name.
Kevin Hunt - Thomas Weisel Analyst
Thomas
Weisel. A couple of follow-up questions. To go back to some of the earlier questions about
other bidders I think maybe what people are getting at is there a potential for other bidders to
come in now? Or was that exhausted?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Well, I guess we cant prevent anyone who sees a greater value here from bidding. But
what we are focused on is working together with Komag to get this deal closed and to move forward
with what we think is a very good deal for the Komag shareholders and a very positive forward
opportunity for Western Digital and for the employees of Komag.
22
Tim Harris - Komag CEO
Kevin, this is Tim Harris. Id just add that we believe that this combination is really logical and
compelling, and our goal is to close the transaction and begin the integration as soon as possible.
Kevin Hunt - Thomas Weisel Analyst
Okay. One other follow-up, as well. Kind of
looking at sort of where Komags capacity is, at least
my understanding of it is in Western Dig. units, you should have enough capacity to meet all your
needs for the next say 12 months where all those guys you get Hitachi to say go to zero. Should
we be thinking then that youre not going to be spending a lot of incremental CAPEX to expand
capacity of your internal over the next couple of years then, if you,
as you implied, are going to
do 10% or 20% to 30% external still?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
I think as weve indicated, Kevin, the capital that Tim has outlined in the $80 million a year
addresses the continuous rolling upgrade and maintenance of the current installed capacity.
Kevin Hunt - Thomas Weisel Analyst
Okay. So
theres no real need to have any incremental or new capacity?
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Not in the medium term here.
Kevin Hunt - Thomas Weisel Analyst
Okay. Thank you.
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
So we have time for one more question and then well need to close out.
Operator
One moment for the next question. At this time we have no further questions. I would like to turn
the call over to Mr. John Coyne.
John Coyne - Western Digital Corp. President, CEO
Okay, well, Id like to thank you all for
participating today. Were very excited by this
combination with Komag. We welcome them to the Western Digital
family, and were looking forward to
the ability to further improve our performance, which we will report to you again in July. Thank
you very much.
23
Additional Information
The tender offer for the outstanding common stock of the Company has not yet commenced. This
document is for informational purposes only and is not an offer to buy or the solicitation of an
offer to sell any securities. The solicitation and the offer to buy shares of the Companys common
stock will be made only pursuant to an offer to purchase and related materials that WD intends to
file with the SEC on Schedule TO. The Company also intends to file a solicitation/recommendation
statement on Schedule 14D-9 with respect to the offer. The stockholders and other investors should
read these materials carefully because they contain important information, including the terms and
conditions of the offer. The Companys stockholders and other investors will be able to obtain
copies of these materials without charge from the SEC through the SECs website at
www.sec.gov, from the Information Agent named in the tender offer documents, from WD (with
respect to documents filed by WD with the SEC), or from the Company (with respect to documents
filed by the Company with the SEC).
Safe Harbor
This transcript contains forward-looking statements that are subject to certain risks and
uncertainties and are subject to change at any time. Factors that could cause actual results to
differ materially include, but are not limited to, costs related to the proposed tender offer and
merger, the risk of failing to meet the minimum tender condition or obtain any required stockholder
or regulatory approvals or satisfy other conditions to the transaction, the risk that the
transaction will not close or that closing will be delayed, the risk that our business will suffer
due to uncertainty related to the transaction and other risks related to our business set forth in
our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission, including the Companys Quarterly Report
on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended April 1, 2007. There can be no assurance that the tender offer
or any other transaction will be consummated. The forward-looking statements involve known and
unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that are, in some cases, beyond our control. We caution investors
that any forward-looking statements made by us are not guarantees of future performance or events.
We disclaim any obligation to update any such factors or to announce publicly the results of any
revisions to any of the forward-looking statements to reflect future events or developments, except
to the extent required by law.
24